If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). Is she worth foregoing the Black Star? 1) Equip Soul trap 2) Cast it on a mammoth 3) Kill mammoth within 30 seconds 4) Do so every time you need to refill the star. that are always Grand. Azura, and is one possible reward for the quest \. So my question is, which one gives the good ending, Aranea it Nelacar? If you bring it to Nelacar, the game states you will only be able to use it to trap "black" souls, and nothing else. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any size soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). Ilinaltas Deep is broken into two sections. it The Black Star that can only capture black souls i.e human souls In the long run, I would choose the black star - soul gems become so common in the later game in comparison to black ones (I have found 2 black ones, and 60+ others). Dialogue If your character is good, giving it to Azura may be the right choice so humanity can never possess such a powerful artifact. "My days at the College are long behind me, but I prefer to stay close by. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. 2) Aela the Huntress. I've already corrected it for future experiments." It can be used to enchant or recharge powerful items. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. This fight is more difficult than any you faced in the Deep. With regular Soul Gems, you only get one use before the gem breaks. A subreddit dedicated to the Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. ( A girl said this after she killed a demon and saved MC). So unless you really want that follower, I'd suggest going for the Black Star. We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup, Screenshot of the Week #85 [Submissions Closed - Vote Now!]. Cookie Notice If you don't use enchanting much, take Star to Azura instead. While Azuras Star can only capture White Grand Souls, The Black Star can trap Black Souls. No, everything is quite all right. The quest tied to Azuras Star is called The Black Star. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! My Khajiit assassin worships Azura since she figures heavily in the Khajiit creation myth, so she returns the gem to Aranea. Kredi notunuzu ykseltiyoruz! Hell be hesitant to tell you anything about Azuras Star at first. Personally, I wouldn't give it back, the other daedric princes are pretty honest about themselves, Azura likes to think she's kinder or more benevolent than she actually is. You're probably the only 'mortal' who could teach Azura a lesson in humbleness and get away with it. If you head to the college, you can speak with Faralda or Sergius. I have looked up what the advantages of both giving the star to Aranea or Nelacar are, and it seems that Nelacar is the way to go. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. He will be accompanied by three Dremora during the fight. If youre a Daedra Worshipper you could bring it back to Azura to gain her favour, the favour of a Daedric Prince. Honestly, The Black Star is probably the better of the two items, because NPCs are probably more common enemies, and they all give Black Souls, the equivalent of only the most powerful creature souls. These souls are always Grand-level and are much more common than White Grand Souls. I dont know if youve ever tried to fight an Ice Mage at level five, but I promise you its not a fun experience. ", Nelacar: "I'm sorry, could you describe the smell?" Which is better Azura's Star or the Black Star? So Azura is really an evil god using the illusion that She is good and hiding her darkness behind a veil of white and light. After leaving college, he has returned to this out of the way place, the reason being that he still has research to do, and that being close to his former colleagues is convenient. Azura's Star is a Daedric artifact of the Daedric Prince Azura, and is one possible reward for the quest "The Black Star." . These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. I wouldnt lose sleep (or significant game progress) as a result of your choice soul gems are reasonably common, even black ones, so Azuras Star is not particularly essential in either form. Overall, it seems like that Azura's Star is better for recharging stuff and The Black Star for enchanting. Black Star always. These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. They were worshipped by the Chimer prior to the apotheosis of the Tribunal and their becoming the Dunmer. Recovering from a blunder I made while emailing a professor, Acidity of alcohols and basicity of amines. The numbness will pass. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? Who is the most powerful follower in Skyrim? Its one of the rare unique items that I actually use rather than lock up in my trophy room, and thats really saying something. Secondly, while it can trap Grand Souls, it cant trap Black Souls. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). However, for roleplaying purposes, 9/10 times I'd go with Azura's Star, even though it is not as good. What is the difference between the black star and Azuras Star? It captures both types of souls and you have to fight the same fight with either choice. Still, good and evil are terms that mean nothing to the Daedra, so its not like Nelacar is lying exactly. The Black star is the most useful of the two given how many bandits we have in this game, but later on Soul gems start dropping like rain so its not really needed. Should I bring Azura's Star to Nelacar or aranea? To keep his identity cloaked, he is referred to as "an elven mage who studies the stars." Either way, youll be presented with a choice here. Otherwise, youll have to take your time, picking off each of the Churls one by one. If possible, you should try to rush down Malyn and kill him as soon as possible. In Winterhold, you have a couple of options. Go to the Shrine of Azura. After acquiring the broken Azura's Star, the Dragonborn can bring it to either Aranea Ienith or Nelacar, both of whom will task them with evicting Malyn Varen's soul from the artifact. Malur Seloth desires to keep up his appearance as a mage for the Jarl of Winterhold, and asks the Dragonborn to steal Nelacar's Staff of Arcane Authority. She is one of the few that arent fully evil but shes not exactly pure too, depends what youd prefer I guess, I always take it to azura so the dark elf becomes available as a follower. Not only do you have to deal with Malyns spells, but he also has three Dremora Churls that youll need to deal with. Azuras Star is capable of doing the same, except it can Trap any souls BUT Black ones, so if it cant be trapped by the Black Star, Azuras Star can hold it. So, what does Azuras Star actually do? Additionally, bringing the Star to Aranea makes her available as a follower. Answer: You use Azuras Star the same way you would use any Soul Gem. He can be found at The Frozen Hearth where he runs a small shop. Azuras Star is a powerful Daedric Artifact, similar to a Soul Gem, but unique in that it is reusable. Help find and repair Azuras Star. What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant? Nelacar is a former instructor at the College of Winterhold. If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section). I've personally found plenty of grand and black soul gems, so I don't need either of those. Slightly shocked that the Dragonborn came to this knowledge, she directs them to the The Frozen Hearth where an Altmer named Nelacar is encountered. *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Hopefully, this guide will make the process of obtaining and using it as simple as possible. As Ive just said, that means you lose out on access to Black Souls. Speaking with him reveals that there exists a soul gem which can be reused: Azura's Star. Its towards the Northwest part of the lake and is so big you shouldnt be able to miss it. What is the best thing to do with Azuras Star? I expect a bit of animosity now and then." The sooner you get the star, the more use you get from it. Azura's Star or The Black Star? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each version of Azura's Star? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each version of Azura's Star? These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. The reverse could also be said as well. Its basically the azura star, but better. Head to the Shrine of Azura. I included a complete walkthrough of The Black Star earlier in this Azuras Star guide. In terms of powergaming it'd be take the Black Star every time. Given that its the location of Azuras Star, this means you cant just head there directly before speaking to Aranea of Nelacar. For Azura's Star, a refillable grand soul gem, take the Star to Aranea Ienith, forcing the Dragonborn to enter the star by Azura and enter into combat with Malyn after a short dialogue. Like regular soul gems, Azura's Star has the ability to trap white souls , or those of creatures. Very little is known about Azuras Star, including its origin and creation. Nelacar: "Are you referring to your other customers? The shrine is just South of Winterhold, so you shouldnt have any trouble finding it. He will ask you to bring him Azura's Star, a powerful soul gem which will not be destroyed upon usage and can be refilled an unlimited amount of times. Exactly how good of a follower is Aranea Ienith? At the end of the dungeon, youll find Malyn Varen looking a bit worse-for-wear. Regardless of how you deal with Malyn, youll be pulled out of the star once hes defeated. While giving the Star to Nelacar does not provide a companion option, the Black Star has the advantage of a much more abundant source of grand souls, as all black souls are of the grand level. The citys steward, Malur Seloth will ask you to steal it for him. Black Souls are always Grand-level, making them incredibly powerful and much more abundant than White Grand Souls. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? Next to the Grimoire will be the Broken Azura Star. It is highly recommended that you do not give this artifact to Martin for the Blood of the Daedra quest. Creatures, undead, beasts, or any other non-NPC) have white souls. Has two beds on the main level, and another two in the cellar where Eirid and her parents sleep. Is there a reason you're asking me?" Interestingly, if one goes for The Black Star then we dont get the option to have Aranea Ienith as a follower. Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. After that, it's really just a matter of personal preference which artifact you're willing to part with. In comparison, you can get the same soul from bandits, sneak killing guards, or killing sprees. Azuras Star only traps white souls. Having an infinite Soul Gem from the start of the game is extremely valuable and can save you a lot of time, and money when it comes to getting a head start on your Enchantment skill. The game has loads of soul gems, no problems recharging anything ever. Azura's Star. Where should I take Azura's Star? [duplicate]. You can say: Here. Nelacar is an Altmer sorcerer and former member of the College of Winterhold, currently living in the Frozen Hearth inn in Winterhold.He was asked to leave the college due to some failed experiments. Malyn managed to transfer his soul into the star and has gone a little bit nutty as a result. New main objective: Bring the Star to Aranea or bring the Star to Nelacar Before deciding who to give the Azura's Star to, you will need to leave this place. However I find the Black Star more useful, since every simple bandit, foresworn or whatnot has a grand soul that fills the Black Star fully with tasty soul energy. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I always get the black star because I never get companions on any of my character. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Could have had a nice little quest line but nope nothing, not even a line from her. The Frozen Hearth is the inn in Winterhold. oh, what was the name of that quest-related weightless sword with soul trap? Shes like having two extra people because her first attack is to pop atronachs. Apparently The Black Star can capture any kind of soul at the moment. The quest brings you to Ilinaltas Deep, the location that houses the broken version of Azuras Star. What happens to the blades if you don't kill Paarthurnax? Answer: Objectively, The Black Star is better than Azuras Star. However, whether this mystery is intentional, or simply a result of a lack of worldbuilding, is unclear. Best answer If you return to Aranea, you get Azura's Star which is like a permanent grand soul gem and you get Aranea as a follower if you return star to Nelacar, you get the Black Star which can trap black souls I would say, if you are into enchanting then go with Nelacar, otherwise go with Aranea for more info, see here: How can we prove that the supernatural or paranormal doesn't exist? Hell also tell you that the last location of both Malyn and the star is Ilinaltas Deep. Who should you bring the black star to? Ilinaltas Deluge is no different from the Deep. Nelacar ending 6:25 This is the second part of the mission after getting the gem, both endings here i personally think that turning it into an endless black . Dagur: "This, this is why people have a problem with your college, Nelacar. Eventually, the quest will take you to Ilinalta's Deep, a partially-flooded and ruined former Imperial fort. Also, the amount of creatures you can actually get grand souls from are very small - I believe it's giants, mammoths, dragons (maybe? For the Black Star, a refillable black soul gem, take the star to Nelacar, where he will place the Dragonborn inside the star where Malyn will have to be defeated. capture only creature souls. First, Azuras Star will fill up before any Soul Gem in your inventory. For Grand souls go Giant and mammoth hunting. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. Should I bring the star to Nelacar or Azura? Dagur: "Like some horrible monster was turned inside out, and then exploded. The ability to capture any soul is just too useful. He sells apparel, scrolls, books (many spell tomes), and miscellaneous items (soul gems . It can be used to enchant or recharge powerful items. Maybe this is my chance to make things right. What is the purpose of this D-shaped ring at the base of the tongue on my hiking boots? Brace yourself. Speak to Azura. The Black Star is Better as Black/Human Souls are More Powerful than Normal \. Youll have to take care of some more Conjurers and Skeletons, which again will give you trouble if youre not adequately leveled and geared up for fighting magic users. Nelacar is an Altmer mage exiled from the College of Winterhold for "bad research." However, I do not know which one is the good and which is the bad ending for the quest. All black souls are of the grand level. A good person would never never never use Black Soulgems though. On his word alone you're going to tee off a goddess and let him basically render you "mostly dead" and under his complete thralldom. Nonetheless, I don't see any evil in Azura. Nelacar will explain that a Dunmer named . No, once youve finished this quest theres no in-game method of converting the star from one form to another. The Black Star is Better as Black/Human Souls are More Powerful than Normal White Souls Such as Animals etc.. Why are Suriname, Belize, and Guinea-Bissau classified as "Small Island Developing States". As soon as hes dead, youll be pulled out of the star regardless of what state the Dremora are in. Andy durkan Posts: 3459 Joined: Fri Aug 03, 2007 3:05 pm Thu Jun 07, 2012 8:35 am I always pick Nelacar over Aranea. Why can I fill my black star by soul trapping a mammoth? My question is, which choice is better in the long run? If youre only aiming for high-level souls, youll either need to prioritize those targets, or youll have to switch to a non-soul trapping weapon. The difference is the Star's use afterwards. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia? m If you're evil then taking it to Nelecar and gaining the Human Soul Devouring, Black Star, may be more appropriate. Talk to him about the mark and he will say I have no idea what youre talking about. You'll pass by Mount Anthor, and the dragon shacked up there may attack you. This version of the star is capable of capturing Black Souls. Dervenin is a Bosmer servant of the Daedric Prince Sheogorath, who refers to him as luggage.. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. The loot inside the chests will be random, but there are some decent static goodies lying around the place. ncdu: What's going on with this second size column? What is the most powerful potion in Skyrim? Should I bring the star to Nelacar or Azura? I wouldnt lose sleep (or significant game progress) as a result of your choice soul gems are reasonably common, even black ones, so Azuras Star is not particularly essential in either form. Is it possible to rotate a window 90 degrees if it has the same length and width?